Review of the 98th Academy Awards: Unexpected Outcomes and Notable Absences

Roger Ebert

Pulitzer Prize-winning film critic whose reviews and essays defined cinema criticism for decades.

The 98th Academy Awards delivered a night filled with unexpected results and moments that challenged pre-show predictions. From the top awards to technical aspects, the ceremony kept both industry insiders and the general public on the edge of their seats, prompting discussions about the evolving landscape of cinematic recognition.

This year's Oscars were characterized by a series of surprising victories and notable omissions, reshaping the narrative of a typical awards season. While some anticipated favorites missed out on accolades, others achieved significant milestones, including a historic tie in the Live Action Short Film category and a groundbreaking win for Best Cinematography. The event also drew attention for its production quality, with several technical issues impacting the broadcast experience.

Unexpected Triumphs and Unforeseen Rejections

The 98th Academy Awards brought forth several unexpected outcomes, redefining the achievements and disappointments of the night. The coveted Best Picture award went to "One Battle After Another," triumphing over "Sinners" in a fiercely contested race, despite "Sinners" holding a record number of nominations. This victory underscored the unpredictable nature of the Academy's choices, as pre-ceremony discussions had indicated a much closer competition. Similarly, the Best Actor category saw Michael B. Jordan emerge victorious for his compelling dual performance in "Sinners," overcoming Timothée Chalamet, whose role in "Marty Supreme" was initially considered a strong contender. Chalamet's film ultimately left the ceremony without any awards, highlighting the dramatic shifts in critical acclaim as the season progressed. These results collectively painted a picture of an awards show that defied conventional wisdom and delivered genuine surprises.

Beyond the major categories, the awards night was marked by additional unforeseen twists. Francine Maisler, the casting director for "Sinners," failed to secure the inaugural Oscar for casting, an award many believed she was destined to win for her widely praised work on the vampire epic. Instead, Cassandra Kulukundis received the honor for her contributions to "One Battle After Another." In a heartwarming moment of recognition, actors Paul Mescal, Gwyneth Paltrow, and Chase Infiniti, who were considered acting snubs, were given the platform to introduce the casting director nominees, acknowledging their strong performances in a unique way. The Live Action Short Film category delivered a rare tie, with both "The Singers" and "Two People Exchanging Saliva" sharing the award—a phenomenon that has only occurred seven times in Oscar history. Furthermore, Autumn Durald Arkapaw made history by becoming the first woman and first woman of color to win Best Cinematography for her work on "Sinners," a win that was closely watched as another battle between "One Battle After Another" and "Sinners." The documentary feature category also saw an upset, with "Mr Nobody Against Putin" winning over "The Perfect Neighbor," a film widely expected to take home the prize. Adding a touch of irreverence, Kieran Culkin's acceptance speech included a sharp, unexpected remark about Sean Penn's absence, further contributing to the night's memorable moments. Even the Animated Short Film category surprised pundits, as "The Girl Who Cried Pearls" clinched the award over the predicted favorite, "Butterfly."

Technical Glitches and Unconventional Integrations

The 98th Academy Awards were not only defined by their winners and losers but also by several notable technical issues and unexpected brand presence that impacted the overall viewing experience. Throughout the evening, the live broadcast encountered problems with both camerawork and audio mixing. Multiple instances of fumbled shots, incorrect blocking, and missed celebrity reactions, such as the absence of certain stars during the Rob Reiner tribute, detracted from the visual fluidity of Hollywood's biggest night. These visual missteps prevented viewers from fully immersing themselves in the glamour and emotional resonance of the event. Concurrently, the audio engineering faced criticism, particularly during Barbra Streisand's heartfelt tribute to Robert Redford, where a piano accompaniment inexplicably overwhelmed her speech, making it difficult for the audience to fully appreciate her words. These technical shortcomings, while perhaps minor individually, collectively created an uneven and at times frustrating broadcast for viewers.

Beyond the production challenges, the ceremony also raised eyebrows with its prominent and unconventional brand integration. Viewers observed a surprisingly high frequency of Burger King commercials, leading to comments and jokes about the fast-food chain's pervasive presence. The extensive advertising campaign, which humorously centered on the idea of their Whoppers being "less terrible now," felt almost as prevalent as the discussions around the films themselves. This unexpected level of commercial saturation sparked conversations about the evolving methods of brand engagement during high-profile events like the Oscars, and how such integrations might influence the audience's perception of the show. The blend of technical missteps and an unusually strong commercial presence contributed to the unique and often unpredictable character of the 98th Academy Awards, leaving an impression that went beyond the traditional focus on cinematic achievements.

you may like

youmaylikeicon
Historic Tie at the Oscars 2026: Two Live-Action Short Films Share the Win

Historic Tie at the Oscars 2026: Two Live-Action Short Films Share the Win

By Roger Ebert
Barbra Streisand Pays Tribute to Robert Redford at Oscars with 'The Way We Were' Rendition

Barbra Streisand Pays Tribute to Robert Redford at Oscars with 'The Way We Were' Rendition

By Mindy Kaling
Accessing 'The Bachelorette: Before the First Rose' - Your Guide to Streaming

Accessing 'The Bachelorette: Before the First Rose' - Your Guide to Streaming

By Ricky Gervais
Rachel McAdams' Touching Tribute to Diane Keaton at the 2026 Oscars

Rachel McAdams' Touching Tribute to Diane Keaton at the 2026 Oscars

By Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
Paul Thomas Anderson Secures First Oscar for 'One Battle After Another'

Paul Thomas Anderson Secures First Oscar for 'One Battle After Another'

By Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
Cassandra Kulukundis Secures Historic Oscar for Casting in 'One Battle After Another'

Cassandra Kulukundis Secures Historic Oscar for Casting in 'One Battle After Another'

By Mindy Kaling
Conan O'Brien's Sharp Wit Shines at the Oscars, Defending Artists and Stirring Laughter

Conan O'Brien's Sharp Wit Shines at the Oscars, Defending Artists and Stirring Laughter

By Ta-Nehisi Coates
Kevin O'Leary's Oscar Red Carpet Outfit Causes a Stir

Kevin O'Leary's Oscar Red Carpet Outfit Causes a Stir

By John Lasseter
Daniel Radcliffe Reflects on His Most Memorable Harry Potter Stunt and Overcoming Near-Drowning Incident

Daniel Radcliffe Reflects on His Most Memorable Harry Potter Stunt and Overcoming Near-Drowning Incident

By Mindy Kaling
Oscar's In Memoriam Segment Sparks Debate Over Notable Omissions

Oscar's In Memoriam Segment Sparks Debate Over Notable Omissions

By Roger Ebert
Jacob Elordi Honors Long-Standing Promise to Mom for Oscars Debut

Jacob Elordi Honors Long-Standing Promise to Mom for Oscars Debut

By Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
Misty Copeland's Oscar Performance Amidst Timothée Chalamet's Ballet Remarks

Misty Copeland's Oscar Performance Amidst Timothée Chalamet's Ballet Remarks

By Mindy Kaling
Timothée Chalamet's Performing Arts Comments Ignite Oscars Night Banter

Timothée Chalamet's Performing Arts Comments Ignite Oscars Night Banter

By Roger Ebert
Unprecedented Oscar Tie: Live-Action Short Film Category Sees Dual Winners for Seventh Time

Unprecedented Oscar Tie: Live-Action Short Film Category Sees Dual Winners for Seventh Time

By Stephen King
Casting Director Cassandra Kulukundis Creates History at the 2026 Oscars

Casting Director Cassandra Kulukundis Creates History at the 2026 Oscars

By Stephen King